National Toll Free: (877) 655-1661

Guide

Diminished value claims by insurance company

A diminished value claim follows the same steps whichever company is involved, and the result depends on your state’s law and, for a claim on your own policy, the policy wording. These guides cover nine insurers. Each sets out the court decisions that involved that insurer, state by state, and points to its official claims page. One general guide covers the steps they all share.

BBB Accredited Business: see the Autoloss profile on the Better Business Bureau
Every report reviewed byOwner, Monica FisherLicensed Auto Appraiser · Court Expert Witness

Each insurer guide below reports what courts decided in cases involving one insurer and says which state each decision comes from. For GEICO, USAA and Liberty Mutual, most of the rulings concern totaled cars, so those guides keep diminished value and total-loss decisions in separate sections. None of it predicts how a company will handle your claim. For what the loss is and how it is measured, start with our diminished value appraisal page. If a claim has been reduced, denied or left unanswered, the guides under “When a claim stalls” set out the rules that apply, starting with why insurers deny or reduce diminished value claims. Autoloss is independent and is not affiliated with or endorsed by any insurer named here; company names are used only to identify them.

Start here

The steps common to every insurer

Read this first. The insurer guides link back to it instead of repeating it.

Rulings in five or more states

Insurers with diminished value rulings in five or more states

Companies whose policies or claims produced appellate diminished value decisions in at least five states in our research.

Reviewed and approved by Monica Fisher, Owner · Oregon DMV vehicle appraiser certificate V26-105 · North Carolina appraiser license 7941001

Free Claim ReviewCall Us